
Your SEO report says traffic is up. Good news, perhaps. But are the right people arriving, finding what they need and taking the next step?
We look at search performance as a sequence: visibility, visits, useful actions and commercial outcomes. A problem at one stage calls for a different response from a problem at another. More visitors will not fix an enquiry form that does not work.
The measures below help you follow that sequence. Choose the ones that explain your objective, define them consistently and use the report to decide what needs attention.
Visibility and brand awareness KPIs
Organic search visibility: Track how visible the website is for a defined set of relevant searches. A third-party visibility score depends on that provider’s keyword set and calculation, so it is not a universal measure. The number of ranking keywords can be useful, but relevance and position matter as much as quantity.
Search impressions: Impressions indicate how often a link to your site appeared in search results under the reporting platform’s rules. They show exposure, not visits or proof that someone remembered the brand.
Click-through rate (CTR): In Search Console, CTR is clicks divided by impressions, expressed as a percentage. Review it by query, page, device and search appearance. A change may reflect position, the search result layout or the mix of queries, not simply the quality of a title.
Traffic KPIs
Organic traffic: Monitor users or sessions attributed to organic search and state which measure you are using. Compare equivalent periods and account for seasonality, tracking changes and campaigns that may affect demand.
Traffic by channel: Compare organic search with channels such as paid search, direct, referral, email and social. This helps place SEO within the broader marketing program rather than judging it in isolation.
New and returning users: These measures can help describe how people discover and revisit the site. They are subject to tracking and identity limitations, so they should not be treated as a complete count of new or loyal customers.
Conversion and key-event KPIs
Desired actions from organic traffic: Track meaningful actions such as a completed enquiry, booking or purchase. Configure the event to represent a successful action rather than simply a button click, and test that it is not counted more than intended.
Key-event rate: In Google Analytics 4 (GA4), important interactions can be marked as key events. State whether a rate is based on users or sessions and which action it includes. Avoid combining minor engagement events and qualified enquiries into one unexplained total.
Contribution across the customer journey: Organic search may introduce a customer who returns through another channel before enquiring or buying. Review the available attribution and path reports, including their model and lookback settings, then compare the picture with sales records. Record what the data can show and where the journey remains incomplete.
Lead quality and revenue: Where reliable information is available, connect website enquiries with the sales process. Ten suitable enquiries may be more valuable than a much larger number of irrelevant submissions.
Page and content optimisation KPIs
Keyword rankings: Track positions for searches that matter to the business, using a consistent location and device. Search Console’s average position and a rank-tracking tool’s point-in-time result are different measures and should be labelled accordingly.
Landing-page performance: Review which pages attract organic visitors, what those visitors do and whether the page answers the intended need. Look beyond the homepage to service, product and informational pages with a defined role.
Bounce rate: GA4 defines bounce rate as the percentage of sessions that were not engaged. It is not simply the percentage of people who viewed one page and left. Read it alongside engagement and key events, and check the property’s engagement settings before comparing reports. See Google’s engagement rate and bounce rate guidance.
Engagement KPIs
Engagement time: Average engagement time helps indicate how long the site was actively in use, rather than merely open in a background tab. Check whether the report expresses the measure per user or per session.
Views per session: This can help show whether people explore related pages, but a higher number is not automatically better. A visitor may find an answer immediately, while another may view many pages because navigation is confusing.
Useful interactions: Where relevant, measure actions such as viewing a product demonstration or accessing a resource. Choose events that support the page’s purpose rather than treating every interaction as commercial success.
Technical SEO KPIs
Page experience and loading performance: Review loading, responsiveness and visual stability using appropriate performance tools. Distinguish real-user field data from a single laboratory test. Better performance supports usability, but a perfect tool score does not guarantee rankings.
Mobile experience: Check important pages on smaller screens for readable text, usable navigation, working forms and content that fits the viewport. Follow the same enquiry or purchase journey a customer would, and record where it becomes difficult. A score can flag an issue; using the page helps explain what needs fixing.
Crawling and indexing: Monitor whether important, intended-to-be-indexed pages can be accessed and appear in the index. Crawling problems and indexing exclusions are not the same thing, and some exclusions are deliberate. Prioritise unexpected problems affecting valuable pages rather than trying to make every URL indexable. Google’s technical requirements also make clear that eligibility does not guarantee indexing.
Backlink KPIs
New links and referring domains: Monitor relevant links earned from other websites, considering unique referring domains as well as total links. Large quantities alone do not demonstrate a successful strategy.
Relevance and quality: Assess the context, audience and editorial value of a link. Third-party authority scores are provider estimates, not Google’s own scores or a guarantee of ranking improvement.
Lost links: Investigate meaningful losses and whether a broken destination or changed page needs attention. Not every lost link requires recovery, and low-value links should not distract from more useful work.
Turning the report into a decision
Start with the business objective, choose the measures that explain progress and use consistent definitions. A useful report should distinguish what changed, the evidence behind the interpretation and the action to take next.
Need help setting up or developing your marketing measurement? Speak with the Mind Methods team about the outcomes you need to understand and the information already available.
About the author
Article by Simon Tokic. Simon’s interests include basketball, music and surfing, although much of his time is spent applying fundamental marketing principles in strategic and creative ways. Before running Sydney marketing agency Mind Methods, Simon worked on brands including Sony Pictures, Universal Pictures, Glad, Chux, Armor All, Clorox, Barbeques Galore and Anglicare.










